Penis

Lady suit: I hate to say it, but Harry Potter’s penis is small.
Hipster girl: What! Nooo!
Lady suit: No, really — it is. He got an erection on stage… and it was just sad. But the weirdest part is that it was bright red, like they had put blush on it or something.
Hipster girl: What the fuck?! My dreams are ruined!

http://overheardinthevalley.blogspot.com/2007/03/goblet-of-fire.html

Chick #1, squinting at laptop: Is that a squirrel?
Chick #2: No. That’s a penis.

Starbucks
Sacramento, California

Overheard by: Awkward!

Old man: You got bats in your belfry?
Jaded 20-something: Yeah, I don't know what I've got in my belfry…

Jersey City, New Jersey

Girlfriend: That's your last drink tonight.
Boyfriend: What? Why?
Girlfriend: Why? Because I don't want to fuck a limp dick and then deal with you shitting yourself again. That's why.

San Francisco, California

Overheard by: Deedle

Coed to another: It's someone picking their nose… but in the thumbnail it looked like a penis

SUNY
New Paltz, New York

Guy #1: So I sent her a picture of my junk.
Guy #2: Right.
Guy #1: Problem solved.

Sandusky, Ohio

Man: Who doesn't love a blowjob!?
Woman: The woman on her knees with a dick in her mouth.
Man: Huh? Really?
Woman: Duhhh!

Manhattan, New York

Agriculture student #1: So she starts screaming and I just knew, so I said, “did you search for “hot dog” without using the safety search?”
Agriculture student #2: Oh, no, hot dog without a fig leaf?
Agriculture student #1: Yeah! And you know how she is, so she starts screaming and freaking out. But it wasn't even a human, it was a dog…

University of Florida
Gainesville, Florida

Bro: We don't put shaving cream on our dicks, we put it on our faces.

Illinois State University

Overheard by: Eddy

20-something guy, browsing toys: So… Do I have a penis face?

Edinburgh
Scotland

Overheard by: Lena